Monday, March 8, 2010

Invisible Hand of Learning (Part 2)

How do we motivate adults to learn new things? This question has been on my mind for months. In my first post for ISTE (The Invisible hand of Learning: Part I) I wrote about how we changed our Professional Development (PD) concept from a top-down to a bottom-up model. The experiment is now on it’s fifth month and so far we have had mixed results.

On the positive side, I have noticed that when teachers choose what they want to learn, they are more engaged, more excited and there is a greater chance the tools they learn will be incorporated into their classroom in some way.

The negative is that many teachers are not signing up to learn anything new. Some teachers have even tried to use that time to work on things independently (like checking e-mail or writing a letter to parents) that required no help from me-- and they would like to get credit for workshop hours. This puts me in an ethical bind, but I have been trying to err on the side of being teacher-friendly.

If we took away the 20 hour requirement, what would happen? Would the teachers who drag their feet ever learn anything new? Is it worth it to try to mandate that someone learn something even when they show no interest? For the teachers that use the time to their advantage and are active participants in their own PD, would removing the 20 hours diminish their enthusiasm? It seems like there are some teachers who would rather go home after school and do what they want, but as long as they have to stay and learn, they make the effort. With no incentive to learn, will they continue to learn or will home seem more appealing?

For the remaining few teachers who are ravenous learners, what is the point of removing the 20 hour requirement? If they are learning for their own sake, keeping track of their hours spent learning should have no effect on them one way or the other.

At our school teachers are encouraged, but not required to take workshops in other areas (literacy, classroom management, dealing with ADHD, etc.). Technology is certainly not the only important thing to learn, but for most teachers, it is currently an Achilles heel. Digital Literacy is growing in importance and just this week I came across two examples on Twitter that showcase why we need to be technologically literate.

Example 1- I know someone who was just hired in a social media role for a major academic journal. The journal has a Facebook page, but couldn’t understand why it had no fans. Within minutes at the job, she diagnosed the problem, “turns out they just had the ‘view fan comments’ setting disabled.” Imagine all the feedback they have been missing because of digital illiteracy.

Example 2- Another friend checked his e-mail at work and saw a message sent from his personal e-mail account in his work inbox. When he opened the message he saw it was actually sent from a botnet that had infected his computer. His yahoo account was hacked and had been sending e-mails to everyone in his address book. He quickly changed his password from work and stopped the spamming.

These are just two small examples from the last week. These people were able to solve problems because they were digitally literate. Problems like these will only increase in frequency and magnitude in the coming decades. Digital literacy is as important in 2010 as traditional literacy was in 1910. Teachers need to cultivate both types of literacies in their students. It follows logically that if we are going to teach English Literature, we should know how to read and if we are going to prepare students for the 21st century, we should be digitally literate ourselves.

Building that digital literacy doesn’t necessarily require a certain amount of hours spent learning, however. It just requires some learning goals and possibly proof that learning occurred.

Would it be better to have a “project” requirement?

Meaning, teachers are responsible to planning what they want to accomplish, then taking as much or as little time as it takes to learn how. For example, a teacher may want to use Diigo to have a digital discussion about an article. In August that teacher could say, “For our current events class each Friday, I am going to ask the kids to annotate and write about the articles I post using Diigo.” In order to do this, they would need to spend a certain amount of time learning how to use Diigo, creating an assignment, teaching the children how to use it from home, etc. Maybe instead of having a certain number of hours as their PD requirement, they can set a certain number of lessons? They can fulfill their tech requirement by learning how and then meeting their self-imposed goal of using Diigo each week.

Maybe a teacher wants to start a blog to communicate with parents and children about the topics in their class. They can set a goal of writing a blog post once a week summarizing the weeks lessons and providing food for thought and debate. In order to accomplish this, a teacher will need a certain amount of training and assistance in learning how to embed videos, pictures, moderate comments, etc.

After a few months, the teacher should be so adept at using their new tool that they no longer need much help at all. It might mean less time spent in a workshop learning, but if the end result is genuine tech integration in their learning environment, isn’t that the whole point anyway?

When I see the level of enthusiasm for learning among the faculty, it makes me wonder if having a requirement of 20 hours of PD is a good idea. I can see both sides of the issue, but I am more interested to know: what you think?

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Mumbai

Students:

Your assignment is to watch at least one of the videos below and write a thoughtful, detailed response. Underneath each video are questions and links to start any further research. The questions are there to give you some direction and food for thought. Your essay comment should not simply be short answers to the questions I posted. Your response should be at least 200 words.

Points will be given for the following:
1. Essay is the required length.
2. Essay demonstrates research on the topic.
3. Essay contributes original thought and reflection to the discussion.

**Bonus points will be given to any students who also reply to another student's comment. Replies must be thought provoking or conversation starting. Simply writing, "Good work" will not count.**

Video #1: India in the Past
Partition


Source: Partition Emory University
Source: Partition Wikipedia Entry

What does "partition" mean?
Who ruled India before 1947?
What 3 countries eventually emerged after 1947?
How many wars did India and Pakistan fight after partition?
Do either of these countries have nuclear weapons?

Video #2: India in the Present
Mumbai Attacks



How did the gunmen arrive?
Analyze the terrorists' targets: what did the people who were targeted have in common?
What message were the terrorists trying to express?
Approximately how many people died in the attacks?
What is the historical cause of the problems between Pakistan and India?

Source: BBC Story
Source: Wikipedia-Mumbai Attacks



Video #3: India in the Future
Vision of India 2020


How many people live in India?
How does their economy rank in the world?
How many engineers and scientists does India have?
How does India compare to America?
Do you think India will surpass America as the world's superpower?
Source: Time of India Vision 2020
Source: Khaleej Times: India, China and Next Superpower

Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Invisible Hand of Learning (Part 1)

The Professional Development (PD) program at my school is broken and we need your help to fix it.

For the last seven years we have used what I call a “push” model and it has proven ineffective because it is the embodiment of 20th century learning. 20th Century learning is all about “pushing” information at a group of passive recipients. The recipients are expected to follow detailed instructions, take notes, absorb information and regurgitate it in the form of a new product.

This is the model we have used for our PD and it stinks. It stinks because the culmination of the effort– the new product– was rarely produced and infused into classroom learning. For seven years the Director of Technology has been responsible for researching new tools and approaches, creating handouts, video tutorials and lectures to be delivered to the faculty to help them meet their yearly PD requirement.

Teachers at our school are required to receive 20 hours of training in technology and all 20 hours have been “pushed.” We are nine years into the 21st century and it is time to rethink this 20th Century model of learning. It is time to stop “pushing” and let the faculty “pull.” Self-directed learning is what I call a “pull” model and this year we will try to pull our learning instead of pushing it.

I am very interested in trying to ignite the passion for self-directed learning in my K-8 students yet, until now, I have not tried this approach with our faculty. The problem with the push model is that it is not as customizable. It violates the the laws of supply and demand that make free markets work so well. Economist Adam Smith described the invisible hand as the mechanism through which needs were filled in a free market society. To paraphrase Smith, when a demand arises in the marketplace, a supply quickly follows as if guided by an invisible hand.

Free market economics is successful because it is a “pull” model and PD should be no different. The “push” model is an artifact of not only the 20th century, but of the failed economies of centrally planned communist states. Centrally planned economies failed for the same reason our PD has failed: you can’t make people want something just because you supply it. Demand for something comes first, then the invisible hand guides the supply to meet it.

Businesses do market research all the time to figure out what people want so that they can customize their product to suit the specific tastes of the consumers. These are the ideas I hope to bring into our PD program this year. Instead of the “sage on the stage” paradigm of the push model, I will be working with teachers to customize their own PD. Teachers will tailor their learning to suit their own demands and I will surrender control to the invisible hand.

The pull model is all about collaborating, creating and sharing in the spirit of 21st century learning, but it does not work without a community. As the trainer I am responsible for the supply of information to our faculty but I am also hoping to enlist you, the community, to help supply me with guidance and solutions to problems that arise throughout the year.

This post is part one of what will be a five part series detailing the ups and downs of this experiment.
In order to ensure that the focus of the training is directed at improving instruction in the classroom, I am proposing a few criteria. I would like to know your opinion about the following guidelines:

1. Training to learn how to build and cultivate a Professional Learning Network (PLN) is encouraged.

2. Training to learn how to use technology to transform outdated classroom activities into more modern approaches is encouraged.

3. Training to learn how to use technology to publicize classroom projects and accomplishments to parents and the greater school community is encouraged.

Is this list too broad or too constricting? Your comments and questions will be very valuable to all of us, so please let us know your take.

Thursday, February 19, 2009

Bearing Fruit


It has been less than a month since the Doha trip and the connections I made are already bearing fruit. Sts. Philip and James School may have three global collaborative technology projects lined up for the months of March and April.

We have an environmental project involving students from Oman. We are planning to order reusable grocery bags, add our own designs with the help of our art teacher, work with other schools in international groups, using social technology, to learn about different aspects of environmental education and have a cultural exchange. The project may involve up to 5 countries. We will be giving the reusable bags away at local grocery stores to interested shoppers and the project will culminate with a tree planting on the school grounds. ArborDay.org is a great resource because for a small membership fee will ship you a geographically appropriate tree to plant. They also have detailed instructions on how to plant and care for the tree.
In addition to what we are calling the "Green Bridge Project," we may also have two other projects for April. One project is a multi-media collaboration about internet safety and etiquette with students from Pakistan and the other project involves a cultural exchange/geography lesson using Google Maps with international students from a school in India. We still have some details to work out with all three projects, but when you have a group of enthusiastic teachers involved, most logistical problems seem easy to conquer.

The Flat Classroom Conference was so amazing, I kept saying, "I wish I could bottle this feeling and bring it back with me." We all know that feelings can't fit inside of bottles, but the good news is that thanks to the flattening of the obstacles separating our classrooms, we can recreate that feeling right in our own schools.

I am looking forward to engaging with these fantastic teachers once again and I can't wait to introduce our wonderful students to each other.
Stay tuned . . .